Saturday, 4 June 2011

At least 40 per cent of pupils should take high-quality vocational training that leads directly to a job to cut the youth unemployment rate and boost economic competitiveness, according to Tim Oates, director of research at the Cambridge Assessment exam board.
The thinking behind this is that economies more efficient than the British do have a more vocational option incorporated with their education and they are doing much better. I can easily find another reason why more youngsters should be encouraged to get training for a job; we need more plumbers, farriers and carpenters than we do brain surgeons or Nobel laureates. A young man and an apprentice to my farrier said to me: "Why do I have to muddle through college first before I can start a 5 year long training to become a farrier when I could have started much earlier? I never enjoyed analysing Shakespeare in English anyway." I cannot but agree.

Wednesday, 1 June 2011

No, a G is not a pass

The fact that no college in the land asks for five G grades for entrance, and will instead ask for five C grades, or that no employer is looking to hire pupils with a mixture of D, E, and F grades, that he only wants C grades, should be ignored. The author of this article, Katharine Birbalsingh, was vilified for telling the Conservative party conference last year that her and other schools were failing their students. At the moment hundreds of thousands of students are sitting their GCSE exams (aged 16) and later this year schools will be ranked according to the results. A*-C are the pass grades for an English baccalaureate that the current Government is using to measure performance in English schools. Despite this most people are reluctant to accept that a D, an E or worse, an F or G means the student has not learned enough to get a pass grade (a U means the examiner simply cannot mark the paper, if for instance the student has not put a pen to the paper). How can you say someone has done really well if you cannot say that he or she has done really badly? Most people do not mind telling athletes or footballers they are rubbish when they perform badly but academic performance seems to be taboo to treat in the same way. It is too late to be told the truth of the value of five G's when you try to get a job and are being turned away.

Tuesday, 24 May 2011

Why academies and free schools are good news

I live in a beautiful part of the world if you do not put education into the equation. Apart from the local fee-paying school, which is brilliant as a matter of fact, there is not a lot of choice if you want excellence in education. Beautiful words, too, excellence in education, and often used by politicians. I suppose that means that pupils get an education that can help them reach their potential, and so on. The local schools score pretty mediocre and below in the league tables for GCSE, especially when you add Maths and English as requirements. But things are changing; new and not so new buzz words like Academies and free schools are being heard even out here over the drone of the combine harvesters.
Becky Francis, writing for the Guardian, is unsure what good parental choice really can do to a school that is performing badly. Even if there are good schools to choose from in the neighbourhood - and she argues that is often not the case - the only consequences of allowing pupils to not attend them, is that it is detrimental to those who stay on. I can see her point: those who choose to stay in a sinking school will be deprived of the company of those who leave ( students who want a nicer, safer environment and a better education?) and the situation might spiral downwards. I am sure she is right. Still, that is not a case to take away the choice of not going there. If no one wants to go to the badly performing school it sends a pretty strong message that people are unhappy with that school and that something must be done if it is to survive.
Academies, free schools and homeschooling are not the only roads to eternal bliss but they give freedom to the citizens to choose - either to go down that specific road or go in a different direction altogether.